Imamate and Leadership - Part 6
Chapter 16
Who are Those Capable of
Interpreting Divine Law?
The laws that scholars have laboriously elaborated and compiled over the
ages to meet the needs of different societies have always stood in need
of intelligent and alert interpreters when it came to implementation.
The laws of Islam, although they rest on revealed norms and divine
guidance, are no exception to this rule.
Certain verses of the Qur'an, which is the fundamental and primary
source for deducing anything related to Islam, are not entirely clear in
their purport and signification for they do not yield a single,
categorical sense. Recourse to exegesis in order to clarify points of
ambiguity is therefore necessary.
Furthermore, the Noble Qur'an sets forth the main lines and general
principles of the programs of action Islam proposes in various spheres;
it does not go into the details of every law and prescript. If therefore
someone wishes to obtain comprehensive knowledge of those programs in
their entirety, he cannot content himself simply with the text of the
Qur'an.
The differences of opinion and approach that have arisen with respect to
the meaning of certain verses, as well as traditions of the Prophet,
peace and blessings be upon him and his family, have played a large part
in the distortion and transformation of some of the original concepts of
Islam.
Interested parties and people tied to the ruling establishment have
succeeded in putting forward interpretations that correspond to the
interests of the rulers, a phenomenon that happened repeatedly during
the Umayyad and 'Abbasid caliphates. In such a whirlpool of confusion,
what needs to be done to prevent the truth from remaining unknown? Does
it not appear necessary that recourse should be had to a single learned
authority on jurisprudence, one divinely protected against sin, a man of
independent opinion, having a comprehensive knowledge of the Book, the
heir to the knowledge of the Prophet, in order for him to acquaint us
with the original meaning and purpose of the Qur'an?
An authority who implements the various commands of the Qur'an in a
practical and visible way and who serves as an indisputable marker of
the right and the wrong? The clarifications he makes and the deductions
he draws, being based on the principles of the Qur'an and inspired by
revealed law, will be decisive for all followers of Islam and capable of
ending all differences of opinion: he will be like a compass in the hand
of a distraught captain.
If we do not have recourse to such qualified interpreters of the Qur'an,
we will fall prey to doubt and confusion, or, by following incorrect
interpretations, stray far from the true teachings of the Qur'an.
Imam Ja'far al-Sadiq, peace be upon him, established the greatest center
for the teaching of Islam, training a multitude of scholars whose task
it was to instruct the people and draw their attention to the dangers
posed by the fabricators of hadith. His scientific and intellectual
activity served to offset the waves of corruption that were unfurling at
the time, as well as the erroneous concepts and biased theories the
ground for which had been prepared by the political situation of the
day.
One day, a group of the companions and students of the Imam, men who
bequeathed to the ummah a great legacy of knowledge that they derived
from him, were gathered in his presence. The Imam addressed Hisham b.
Hakam who was present among them: "Will you not tell us something about
the conversation you had with 'Amr b. 'Ubayd?" He replied: "I would be
embarrassed to say anything in your presence." But the Imam insisted,
and so Hisham b. Hakam spoke as follows:
"I learned that Amr b. 'Ubayd had begun to assume some religious
responsibilities, establishing a teaching circle in the mosque at Basrah.
This news disturbed me, and so I set out for the mosque, where I found
him sitting, answering people's questions. I approached him and said: 'O
scholar, I am a stranger here; will you permit me to ask a question?' He
replied that I might, so I asked him:
'Do you have eyes?' 'Amr responded: 'Young man, what kind of a question
is this? Why ask about something you can see to be true?' But I
persisted, asking him to answer my question. He consented, so I repeated
the question. When he answered in the affirmative, I next asked him;
'What do you do with eyes?' 'I see colors and people.' Then I asked; 'Do
you have a nose?' 'Yes.' 'What do you do with your nose?' 'I smell
things.' 'Do you have a mouth?' 'Yes.' 'What do you do with it?' 'I
taste the food that I eat.' 'Do you have ears?' 'Yes.' 'What do you with
them?' 'I hear sounds.'
"'Now, do you have a heart?' 'Yes.' 'What do you do with it?' 'My heart
is an instrument of weighing and measuring; by means of it I assess the
truth or falsehood of whatever knowledge comes to my senses and limbs.'
"Then I asked: 'Can any limb or member dispense with the heart (qalb)?'
"'No.'
"'Even if all limbs and members are completely healthy?'
"'Young man, whenever any bodily sense is mistaken in its perceptions or
doubts their accuracy, it has recourse to the heart in order to resolve
its doubts and gain some measure of confidence and certainty.'
"'So the role of the heart with respect to the members and limbs is, in
accordance with divine command, to remove error, confusion, and
bewilderment?' "'Yes.'
"'So the existence of the heart in man is a necessity without which his
members and limbs lose their sense of direction?'
'Yes.'
"'O Abu Marwan, God has not left your senses and limbs without a guide
to rectify their errors and doubts. Is it then possible that He should
leave human society, despite all the dissension and ignorance that beset
it, to its own devices, without any leader to guide it? A fitting leader
who will remove all confusion and error?'
"'Amr remained silent for a while, and then he said:
"'Are you not Hisham b. Hakam?'
"'No.'
"'Are you one of his companions?'
"'No.'
"'Where do you come from?'
"'I come from Kufah.'
"Then he said, 'Indeed you are Hisham,' stood up, caused me to sit where
he had been sitting, and remained silent until I got up to leave."
The Imam smiled and said: "From whom did you learn this mode of
argumentation?" Hisham replied: "From you." Then the Imam said: "I swear
by God that this same argument is to be found in the pages revealed to
Ibrahim and Musa." [194]
Men may therefore gain access to the commands and prescriptions of God
only when, after the Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him and his
family, the leadership of the Islamic ummah is in the hands of a person
who is enabled by his proven erudition and spiritual qualities to
expound those detailed injunctions which have not been explicitly
included in revelation but are nonetheless a matter of practical
necessity for human society. In the absence of such leadership, the
ummah will tend to deviate from the principles of Islam and fail to
reach the goal of happiness and the purposes for which it has been
created.
After the Prophet, the Immaculate Imams, committed as they were to
leadership and guidance, did everything possible to disseminate the
teachings of the Qur'an, for years on end and in the midst of swiftly
changing circumstances, and to show the Muslims how to apply those
teachings; they guided and instructed the people in word and indeed. As
a result, the aggregate of their teachings came of form a precious
treasure of learning that was bequeathed to the ummah. Because of its
evidential force, this treasure was uniquely authoritative, and because
of its scope, it offered the means for solving every new problem that
might occur.
Everyone knows that the caliphs who succeeded the Messenger of God,
peace and blessings be upon him and his family, knew very little
concerning the ordinances of Islam and the religious needs of the
people. Abu Bakr, the first caliph, is known, for example, to have
transmitted only eighty hadith. [195]
al-Nawawi says the following in his Tahdhib: "Abu Bakr transmitted 142
hadith from the Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him and his family,
104 of which are cited by al-Suyuti in his Tarikh al-Khulafa' and 22 of
which are included by al-Bukhari in his collection." [196]
The religious leader of the ummah who is meant in every respect to aid
and assist his community and to solve their complex religious problems
has so little Islamic consciousness that he finds himself consulting al-Mughirah
b. Shu'bah, an extremely corrupt individual, in order to learn God's
ruling concerning the portion of an estate that goes to his grandmother!
[197]
He even confesses himself, with the utmost frankness, that his religious
knowledge is not superior to that of anyone else, and declares to the
people that if they see him committing an error they should correct him
and instruct him in the proper course of action. For this is what he
says:
"I hold in my hands the reins of your affairs even though I am not the
best among you. If you see that I am treading the right path, then
support me, and if you see me embarking on the wrong course, then guide
me back to the right path. [198]
As for 'Umar, he transmitted no more than fifty authentic hadith from
the Prophet. [199]
In connection with the religious knowledge of the second caliph, it is
reported that someone once went to consult him on a problem that he
faced. He said: "I need to make a total ablution (ghusl), but I have no
access to water; what is my religious duty under these circumstances?"
The caliph answered: "You are relieved of your duty to pray." [200] The
real duty of such a person is, however, spelled out in the Qur'an. (4:43
and 5:6)
Five hadith are narrated on the authority of 'Uthman in the Sahih of
Muslim, and nine in the Sahih of al-Bukhari. [201]
Facts such as these serve to demonstrate the degree of religious
learning possessed by those persons who assumed the leadership of
Islamic society. How then could it be expected that the framework of
divine law should remain immune to change and distortion and that
Islamic society should advance toward its lofty goals? Whoever carries
the burden of leading the ummah must possess extensive religious
awareness and knowledge in order to answer whatever questions and
problems arise, whereas the knowledge that the caliphs had of the
authentic law of Islam was extremely limited.
One day, while preaching from the pulpit, the second caliph was
criticizing a rise in the amount of dowries customarily given and
declared that this increase ought to be prevented. When he descended
from the pulpit, a woman objected to what he had said: "Why is it
necessary to restrict the amount of dowries? Does God not say in the
Qur'an, 'If you have given one of your wives great wealth by way of a
dowry, you must not take back any of it?" (4:20) The caliph realized his
mistake and begged God to forgive him. Then he remarked: "Everyone is
better acquainted with God's commands than is 'Umar." Then he mounted
the pulpit again and retracted what he had said. [202]
As for the religious knowledge of the third caliph, it is enough that we
should refer to the following event
"During the time of his caliphate an unbeliever was killed by a Muslim.
The caliph ordered the murderer to be put to death. But a group of the
Companions of the Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him and his
family, who were present at the time informed the caliph of his mistake
and reminded him that in such cases the murderer should be condemned to
the payment of blood money, as a result of which the caliph rescinded
his order." [203]
Is it fitting that the leadership of Islamic society should be in the
hands of people who by their own admission are so ignorant of the laws
of God's religion, a religion the ordinances of which they are supposed
to expound and to implement? Is it at all conceivable that God should
entrust all the affairs in fact, the destiny of a community that had
been nurtured on revelation and established by the most noble of
creation to people who were not only unable to propel the Islamic ummah
forward and to remove the veil of ambiguity from complex and difficult
questions, but could not even expound the most elementary concerns of
religion or implement the shari'ah?
We leave it those whose intelligences are not fettered by fanaticism or
prejudice to judge the matter.
Notes:
[194] al-Kulayni, al-Kafi, Vol. I, p. 170.
[195] Ahmad b. Hanbal, al-Musnad, Vol. I, pp. 2, 14.
[196] Cited in al-Nawawi, Adwa' 'ala al-Sunnat al-Muhammadiyyah, p. 224.
[197] Malik, al-Muwatta', p.335.
[198] Ibn Sa'd, al-Tabaqat, Vol. III, p. 151.
[199] al-Nawawi, Adwa' p.204.
[200] Ibn Majah, al-Sunan, Vol. I, p.200.
[201] al-Nawawi, Adwa', p.204.
[202] al-Amini, al-Ghadir, Vol. VI, p. 87.
[203] al-Bayhaqi, al-Sunan (al-Kubra), Vol. VIII, p. 33.
Chapter 17
The Imamate and Inner Guidance of Man
One of the functions and attributes of the Imamate (imamah) is to extend
inner guidance to man. This is something different from outer guidance
in matters of law and the shari'ah; it is a distinct and lofty station
bestowed by God on a select and precious few among His creation, men
who, themselves strongly drawn and attracted to God and fully aware of
all the variations of human behavior and the various degrees of faith
and knowledge people possess, can influence their thoughts and inner
beings. They illumine the hearts of the ummah with inner knowledge and
aid them in the refinement of their souls and their inward journeying,
always bearing in mind the great multiplicity to which they are subject.
It then becomes incumbent on men to follow them and to align themselves
with the guidance they provide, thus guarding themselves against falling
into the pit of instinctual desires and corrupt longings.
Some of the great prophets, after their determination and steadfastness
had been duly tested and their spiritual strength had been fully proven,
and they had attained the stage of total certainty, gained this station
of inner guidance with which we are concerned.
Likewise, it can be deduced from numerous verses of the Qur'an that the
Inerrant Imam (Imam al-ma'sum), who is situated at the highest rank of
spiritual life, is also entrusted with the task of inner guidance, for
he is a channel of divine grace which comes to him inwardly from the
suprasensible realm.
The Glorious Qur'an specifies certain conditions for the office of
Imamate: "We have chosen from among them Imams who at Our command shall
guide men to the right path, for they are patient and steadfast and have
certain knowledge of Our signs." (32:24)
What is meant here by guidance is inner guidance, not legal guidance,
for to guide others in an outward sense by exhorting them to follow the
truth is a duty for everyone, according to the command of the shari'ah,
and fulfilling it is not contingent on being an Imam, patient and
steadfast, or having certain knowledge of God's signs, nor is it
necessary to traverse different stages and degrees in order to perform
it. However, guidance in accordance with divine command is a station
that can be attained only through divine appointment, and is possible
only for the one who, when confronted with irksome events and
occurrences, passes the divine test implicit in them by displaying
exemplary powers of endurance; who consistently resists the pollution of
sin and struggles against all forms of lowliness and triviality.
Equipped with such virtues, he attains the lofty rank of the certain
knowledge of God's signs and the station of Imamate, which is also the
station of inner guidance. The Qur'an says: "We have appointed them
Imams in order that they might guide in accordance with Our command"
(21:73), and, in another verse, "A day on which We shall call forth each
group with its Imam." (17:71)
When Ibrahim had completed all the tasks with which God had tested him,
God addressed him as follows: "I appoint you to the station of Imamate
and the leadership of man Ibrahim then asked: 'Will you also grant this
station to my progeny?' God said: 'The covenant of My Imamate will not
be granted to wrongdoers. '" (2:l24)
Several points can be derived from this verse.
First, the Imamate of Ibrahim was connected directly to the manner in
which he had confronted the tests and trials of prophethood. After he
had displayed his strength by passing through all those stages, God
revealed to him that he was to be further honored with the lofty office
of Imamate, with responsibility for the inner guidance of mankind, the
refinement of their souls, the maturing of their spiritual capacities,
and, in general, the preservation of the truth.
Second, Ibrahim was addressed by God in this manner when he was
approaching the final part of his life and at a time when he was fully
established in the rank of prophet and already had responsibility for
the guidance of his ummah in matters of belief and conduct. God
nonetheless promised him an additional station, which proves that the
office of Imamate, with the ability to exercise inner influence on the
ummah in order to advance on the inner path, was a higher and more
exalted office than his prophethood.
Third, immunity from the pollution of sin ('ismah) is one of the
conditions of Imamate. For the verse proclaims that wrongdoers who
transgress the bounds of piety and inerrancy, whether they wrong others
or their own selves, will be denied the rank of Imamate.
Fourth, the Imamate is a divine covenant, bestowed only on the just, the
pious, and the utterly pure; it is only they who aid and guide the ummah.
The Imamate is not, then, a station which is at the disposal of men to
be awarded to whomever they see fit
Fifth, prophethood and Imamate can be combined in a single person, as
was the case with Ibrahim. For he had already received revelation in his
capacity of prophet, correcting men's erroneous beliefs by means of
decisive arguments and proofs, and in the very process of doing this, he
had acquired the strength and capacity needed for inner guidance, so
that the gate of Imamate was opened before him.
Finally, the verse indicates that members of Ibrahim's progeny who are
not wrongdoers (zalimin) will be granted the station of Imamate. There
can be no doubt that the most righteous of God's servants from among
that progeny were the Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him and his
family, and the Inerrant Imams, so they must count as Imams from
Ibrahim's line who were entrusted with inner guidance and the knowledge
of the unseen.
Imam Ja'far al-Sadiq, peace be upon him, is reported in al-Kafi to have
said:
"Before appointing Ibrahim as prophet, God Almighty appointed him His
servant. Before ennobling him with His friendship, He bestowed on him
the rank of messengerhood. Before granting him the rank of Imamate, He
made him His sincere and devoted friend. It was therefore after Ibrahim
had attained a whole series of high ranks that he was given the station
of Imamate." [204]
Numerous traditions exist affirming and emphasizing the need for an Imam
to be present among the people in order to guide them. These traditions
indicate that as long as the human species exist in this world, a proof
of God and the truth must also exist to provide and protect the
intellectual, social and credal framework for the ummah. This proof is
none other than the Imam, the Friend of God, who in his very person is a
living exponent and exemplar of true Islam.
The Commander of the Faithful, 'Ali, peace be upon him, said: "The
Family of Muhammad, peace and blessings be upon him and his family, are
hike the stars; as soon as one of them sets, another rises." [205]
Imam Ja'far al-Sadiq, peace be upon him, said in the course of a sermon:
"God has illumined His religion with the Imams from the Household of the
Prophet and made them the abundant spring from which knowledge of
religion gushes forth. Whoever recognizes the claims of the Imams, based
on sound knowledge and insight, will taste the sweetness of faith and
come to know the luminous and beautiful visage of Islam. For God has
appointed the Imams to be His proof among men and their guide; has
placed on their heads the crown of sublimity and leadership; caused the
light of His Own splendor to shine on their beings; and sustained and
supported them with inexhaustible heavenly power. It is only by means of
causes that God's grace reaches His servants, and God does not accept
men's knowledge of Himself except by means of their recognition of the
Imam.
"The Imam is versed in all the complexities, problems and metaphoric
aspects of revelation, and he is chosen by God from among the
descendants of Husayn, peace be upon him. Whenever an Imam departs for
the realm of eternity to meet God, he appoints another Imam from among
his own offspring in order to illumine the path men should travel. God
has chosen all of them to lead the ummah in order that they should guide
the people and judge justly among them.
"They are among the choice descendants of Adam, Nuh, Ibrahim, and
Isma'il. The jewel of their being shone in the world even before their
bodies were fashioned of clay. God made their existence the substance of
life for all men and the firm pillars of Islam." [206]
He said in another tradition:
"Even if there were only two people heft on earth, one of them would be
an Imam. The last person to close his eyes on the world will be the
Imam, so that no one will be to argue before God that he was left
without an Imam." [207]
al-A'mash asked Imam Ja'far al-Sadiq: "How will people benefit from the
existence of an absent (gha'ib) Imam?" He answered: "In the same way
that they benefit from the sun when it is hidden behind a cloud." [208]
Ishaq b. Ghalib relates the Imam to have said:
"The Imam is designated by God and the Messenger to be God's proof
before men. Through the blessed existence of the Imam a link is
established between God's servants and the suprasensible realm and God's
grace flows down upon them. God will not accept the deeds of His
servants unless they are loyal to the Imam. God does not abandon His
servants to their own devices after creating them; instead, by means of
the Imam, he lays out the path of piety before them and thus establishes
His proof." [209]
Imam al-Baqir, peace be upon him, said:
"I swear by God that from the time God took Adam's spirit and conveyed
him to the realm of eternity, He has never left the earth empty of an
Imam. Hereafter, too, the world will never be without the existence of
an Imam, so that God's proof will always be present among His servants."
[210]
Abu Khalid al-Kabuli says that he once asked the fifth Imam to interpret
the verse "So believe in God and His Messenger and the light He has sent
you." (64:8) The Imam replied: "'I swear by God that that light (al-nur)
is the Imam. The brilliance of the light of the Imam in the heart of the
believer is greater than that of the sun. It is the Imam who illumines
the hearts of the believers. God prevents the brilliance of that light
from reaching the hearts of whomsoever He wills, this being the
explanation for the darkness of their hearts." [211]
al-Saduq writes in his 'Ilal al-Shara'i':
"Jabir once asked Imam al-Baqir, peace be upon him, why men need
prophets and Imams. He replied that the existence of prophets and Imams
is indispensable for the continuance and welfare of the world. For it is
by means of them that God wards off His punishment from men. God says in
the Qur'an: '(O Muhammad) as long as you are among them, punishment
shall not descend on them."' (8:33}
The Most Noble Prophet himself, peace and blessings be upon him and his
family, said:
"Just as the stars bestow safety On the inhabitants of the heavens, the
People of my House grant security to the inhabitants of the earth. If
the stars in the heaven are destroyed, it will be a catastrophe for the
inhabitants of the heavens, and if the People of my House are no longer
to be found among men, the whole earth will be overtaken by disaster.
"What is meant by the People of the House are those leaders obedience to
whom God has conjoined with obedience to Himself in the verse, 'O you
who believe, obey God, the Messenger, and the Holders of authority
'(4:59). The Holders of Authority from the People of the Prophet's House
are adorned with inerrancy and utter purity; they never disobey any of
God's commands and are always guided and supported by Him. Their deeds
are beyond the reach of crookedness and deviation, and their feet are
firmly planted on His straight path. It is through the blessed existence
of these great ones that God's servants receive their sustenance, cities
become prosperous, and the rainfall descends. The Holy Spirit always
accompanies them, and there is never any separation between them and the
Qur'an." [212]
Muhammad b. Fudayl asked Imam al-Rida, peace be upon him, whether the
earth could subsist without an Imam. He answered that it could not.
Muhammad b. Fudayl continued: "It has been related to us from Imam
Ja'far al-Sadiq that the world will never remain without a proof (hujjah)
and an Imam, for were it to do so, the people of the world would
instantly be caught up in God's wrath." The Imam then said: "The earth
will never be without an Imam. Were there to be no Imam, destruction and
collapse would be the ineluctable fate of the world." [213]
Notes:
[204] al-Kulayni, al-Kafi , Vol. I, p. 175.
[205] al-Radi, Nahj al-Balaghah, p. 146.
[206] al-Qunduzi, Yanabi' al-Mawaddah, pp. 23, 524.
[207] 6. al-Kulayni, al-Kafi, Vol. I, p. 180.
[208] al-Qunduzi, Yanabi' al-Mawaddah, p.21.
[209] Hurr al-'Amili, Ithbat al-Hudat, Vol. I, p.247.
[210] al-Kulayni, al-Kafi, Vol. I, p. 179.
[211] Ibid, Vol. I, p. 195.
[212] al-Majlisi, Bihar al-anwar, Vol. XXIII, p. 19.
[213] al-Kulayni, al-Kafi, Vol. II, p. 179.
Chapter 18
The Inerrancy of the Imams and the Necessity of
Belief in it
Throughout the history of Islam, different sects have debated among
themselves the question of whether inerrancy is necessary in prophets
and Imams or not.
The Shi'ah are unanimously agreed on the inerrancy ('ismah) of the
Imams, and they regard only the one who possesses this fundamental
quality as fit for the office of Imamate, given the sensitive and
portentous nature of the office. There is always the danger that a
leader burdened with responsibility for the manifold concerns of the
ummah may knowingly or unknowingly veer in the direction of error, in
which case the honor and values of the ummah will be at risk, with
undesirable consequences for Islamic society as a whole.
Insistence upon inerrancy as a condition for leadership is a hallmark of
the Shi'ah and a proof of the maturity of their religious thinking and
comprehensive grasp of Islam, for with great care and alertness they
have identified who the leader should be and designated inerrancy and
extensive knowledge as two of his inseparable qualities. His inerrancy
and immunity from sin are the result of his piety and self-discipline,
and his knowledge is the result of divine grace and generosity, bestowed
upon him from God's limitless ocean of wisdom. These two qualities are
to be found in combination only in the Imams of the Prophet's Household,
peace and blessings be upon him and his family. The Sunnis accept anyone
as caliph or Imam, without any precondition, and they do not insist on
inerrancy and immunity from sin.
Inerrancy is an inner faculty of self-restraint, springing up from the
great source of faith, piety, and insight; it insures man against all
kinds of sin and moral corruption. This powerful inner attribute,
derived as it is from vision of the suprasensible world and the very
essence of all creation, is so effective that it prevents man from
embarking on any kind of sin or rebellion, whether small of great, open
or hidden.
When we say that the factors leading to rebellion and sin have no effect
on such a person, we do not mean that in accordance with divine with and
decree an overwhelming force prevents him from being attracted to sin,
so that the capacity to sin and disobey is removed from him. It is
rather that the possessor of inerrancy, while having freedom to choose
and to act, is prevented by his awareness of the majesty and constant
presence of God from approaching the sphere of sin. He has had such
success in establishing the dominion of piety over his soul that he
cannot even conceive of sin in the purified sanctuary of his mind, so
that the possibility of his actually committing a sin is reduced to
zero.
Generally speaking, the commission of any undesirable act is the result
of not knowing how ugly the act is and how harmful its consequences are.
Even if one is aware to a certain extent of the ugliness of the act and
his faith seeks to warn him and alert him to the danger, he is
overpowered by his desires and loses all self-control, and is drawn to
impurity and sin. It is only attention to the damaging consequences of
one's deeds, the restraining force of piety, and a powerful sense of
obedience toward divine law, that create a certain immunity in man;
there will then be no need for any other means of restraint and control.
Muhammad b. Abi 'Umayr says: "I asked Hisham, the celebrated pupil of
Imam Ja'far al-Sadiq, peace be upon him, whether the Imam possessed the
quality of inerrancy. He answered that he did, and I then asked him to
explain inerrancy to me.
"He said: 'Several things hie at the origin of rebellion and sin -
greed, envy, lust, anger, and so forth and not one of these can
penetrate the being of the Imam. How might he be greedy, considering
that he has everything at his disposal, including even the treasury of
the Muslims? How might he be envious, for only he who is aware of a
station higher than his own can be envious, and no station higher than
the Imamate can be conceived? As for anger, it is impossible that the
Imam be angered by any worldly concern, for God has entrusted to him the
implementation of His laws. But in connection with anything touching on
the hereafter, anger in not at all undesirable. The Imam will never fall
prey to lust, for he is well aware that the pleasures and desirable
things of this world are transitory and valueless when compared to the
reward that God shall bestow on His worshippers on the Day of
Resurrection." [214]
People will submit fully to the requirements of religious duty in
response to the summons of their leader and unquestioningly accept his
commands and instructions when they regard all his orders as being the
command of God, without having doubt on the matter. If someone not be
thoroughly immune to sin and error, can complete trust be placed in his
words or his orders be obeyed with devotion?
The effect of inerrancy is such that it protects man from deception by
the allurements of this world power and position, wealth and possessions
and enables him to remain steadfast in the face of all types of
distraction.
If it is not possible to trust the leader fully, the mission of
religion, which is to enable man to attain perfection, will necessarily
remain unfulfilled, for the credal structure of the religion will be
distorted by inevitable suspicions that the commands and edicts of the
leader are not based on revelation and the authentic principles of
Islam.
In addition, possession of the attribute of inerrancy cannot be
restricted to the period in which the leader of the Muslims actually
exercises the office of Imam. Throughout his life, including the period
before assuming the Imamate, his heart must have been free of all
darkness and his person of all sin. In addition to the fact that sinning
entails a loss of human dignity, people will always suspect of
continuing sinfulness and pollution one whom they know to have erred in
the past, however slightly. This suspicion will in turn rob the
leadership of such a person of all legitimacy. He will no longer be
regarded as an exemplar of piety and purity, as one endowed with unique
virtues.
The bitter memory of a life spent partially in sin and corruption can
never be erased, and it will always serve as a pretext for his
opponents. They will have a powerful and credible tool for attacking him
and destroying his reputation and base of popular support. He will be
unable to defend his honor or answer his critics convincingly.
If we examine the life of the Immaculate Imams, peace be upon them, we
will see that the groups opposed to them, for all their impudence and
shamelessness, never resorted to accusations of corruption in order to
destroy their reputation. If there had been the slightest grounds for
making such an accusation, the enemies of the Imams would never have
remained silent, and the people in general would have entertained doubt
concerning the Imams' pronouncements on matters relating to revelation
and God's law. We read in the story of Musa, peace be upon him, that the
Fir'awn (Pharaoh), that cruel tyrant, unhesitatingly pointed the finger
of accusation at Musa when he confronted him, saying:
"Are you not that child that grew up under our tutelage and spent many
years with us ? Who then committed murder and rebelled against our
divinity?" Musa answered: "Yes, indeed I killed someone, but not
deliberately; my intention was to save an oppressed person, and the
result was and accidental killing. I then fled out of fear of you until
my Lord taught me knowledge and wisdom and appointed me as one of His
prophets." (26:16-19)
The first and most essential condition for the office of Imamate is,
then, inward purity and profound piety, divinely accorded protection
from sin, the possession of a lustrous heart both before and after
appointment to the rank of leader and Imam.
It is true that everyone is exposed to the possibility of error, for the
simple reason that whatever knowledge and information he has consists of
a series of concepts and images acquired by means of the senses and
other ontological faculties, none of which are infallible.
However, the Imam observes the innermost nature of the world, including
its suprasensible aspect, by means of the eye of the heart, and this
grants him access to a whole treasure house of true and certain
knowledge. His perception of reality is not dependent on his senses and
is for this reason immune against error. Fallibility arises only when a
person wishes to apply his mental concepts to the world of external
reality; it does not exist in the case of the Imam who has a direct and
unmediated perception of reality and is inwardly connected with the
essence of all being,
The comprehensive infallibility and inerrancy of the Imam, manifested in
his speech, his acts, and his thoughts, results from his privileged
knowledge of the realm of the unseen. No one can comprehend the totality
of reality by recourse to external and conventional means, and perceive
the true nature of things as they are; it is only divinely bestowed
knowledge, a mode of comprehension derived from the world of the unseen,
that can guide man infallibly to a knowledge of the reality of all
things.
Piety expressing itself in deeds is far more effective than verbal
exhortation in bringing about the moral education of men and advancing
them on the path of spiritual growth. If the one who assumes the task of
the spiritual guidance of the people is lacking himself in spiritual
virtue and no sign of moral purity or practical piety can be discerned
in him, he will be totally unable to fashion upright and exalted human
beings, to exercise any positive role in their development, or to guide
them toward the general goals inculcated by religion.
It may appear that the Qur'an has attributed sins to some of the
prophets. However, the sin must be carefully examined in each case to
gain a proper understanding of the matter. The essence of true sin is to
rebel against God, to disobey His commands, to plunge into the whirlpool
of vice, all of these being acts for which a specific punishment has
been decreed; in this sense, the prophets are completely free of all
sin.
Another kind of sin might be called relative, for its commission does
not entail any specific punishment Even this kind of sin is not to be
expected from those true travellers on the path of God who are in direct
communication with the source of all being and directly perceive all
hidden truths. Given the vision with which they are endowed, it is not
to be thought that they would be unaware of God for even an instant, for
even such temporary inattention would diminish their closeness to God.
Considering the fact that these favored friends of God possess vast
treasuries of faith and knowledge and have direct and precise awareness
of reality, it will be considered a sin on their part if their
orientation to God is interrupted for even a moment, even though such
brief inattention would not occasion so much as a reproach in the case
of lesser persons.
Something similar can be observed in the case of socially prominent
people who carry certain titles and ranks; people have higher
expectations of them than they do of others. Everyone is obliged to try
to fulfil the expectations that others have of him, based on his rank
and position ill society. Sobriety and dignity of speech are expected of
a learned scholar, but not of an illiterate and unlearned man.
It is true that awareness of the undesirable consequences of sin does
not in itself create immunity against sin and that its restraining
influence is neither reliable nor constant. However, a knowledge that is
deeply rooted and shows clearly all the grievous results of sin, a
perception and an awareness that permits the reality of all things to be
seen directly, in such a fashion that limitations of time and space are
transcended, and a lively fear of severe punishment by God - all these
taken together constitute a mechanism which makes the commission of a
sin by a possessor of inerrancy impossible.
No intelligent pilot will consent to take off in a plane which he knows
to be carrying a time bomb and is therefore destined to blow up in
midair. It is not, however, that he has some immunity to this suicidal
course of action built into him, involuntarily; he can freely decide
whether to take off or not. The fact that he refrains from taking off is
because he is fully aware of the disastrous consequences that would
inevitably follow if he did; it is his intelligence and awareness that
guide him and reduce to zero the possibility that he would do so.
This may serve as an illustration for the way in which profound and
immediate knowledge of the fatal consequences of an act can provide
immunity against committing that act, in the most powerful and practical
way imaginable.
The leader of religion is not subject to compulsion or determination in
his obeying divine command or adorning his soul with purity and virtue,
nor does inerrancy negate his possession of free will and choice, in the
sense of making it impossible for him to sin, without any involvement of
his ability to decide.
It is rather that the Imams' constant orientation to the pure essence of
God, their selfless struggles for His sake, their devotion,
self-sacrifice, and exertions in seeking His satisfaction, powerfully
insure these exalted personages against the commission of sin. Although-
they retain the capacity for committing evil deeds, they never pollute
themselves by committing them, and their minds never even incline in
that direction.
Their comprehensive knowledge of the corruption caused by sin, joined to
their thorough awareness of the sublimity of the divine essence,
suffices fully to rein in any instinctual tendencies that might exist in
their beings and to render them steadfast on the path of purity, piety,
and virtue.
Quite apart from the Inerrant Imams, peace be upon them, who are of
course situated at exalted levels of knowledge and insight, there are
those who are not inerrant but are nonetheless sincere and ardent lovers
of God who sacrifice their whole beings for His sake, and effectively
acquire a degree of immunity from sin in their exertions to attain God's
pleasure, so that the mere thought of disobeying divine command has no
attraction for them.
It is of course possible that in their case the desired result is
attained not by breadth of understanding or completeness of awareness,
but by a strong sense of obedience to God, an innate purity of mind
which quells any tendency to sin that may exist within them and leads
them to a categorical rejection of evil.
The commission of a sin arises either from incomplete knowledge of the
ugliness of the sin, unawareness of its evil consequences, deficiency of
intelligence, or feebleness of the will when confronted with the
onslaught of passionate desire. None of these factors can obtain in the
case of one who possesses abundant spiritual knowledge, who perceives in
detailed form all the corruption sin causes, and who has subordinated
his ego to the demands of piety.
In addition, freedom from error and sin is ensured by the protection God
extends for the sake of the correct conveyance of the message. In just
the same way that God watches over the first receipt of revelation by
the Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him and his family, in order to
exclude all error, divinely guaranteed inerrancy is also called for at
this stage in the process. For it is necessary that Cod's message and
commands should be conveyed to mankind without the least error or
mistake, whether intentional or accidental.
Thus the Qur'an says:
"Were it not for God's grace and mercy toward you, a group of God's
enemies would have conspired to make you deviate from the right path.
Thanks to God's kindness, it was only themselves that they caused to
wander from the truth, and they are completely unable to harm you. God
has bestowed on you this Book, wisdom and prophethood, and taught you
what you knew not, for God's kindness to you is great and His favor
unbounded." (4:111)
The propagation and implementation of God's revealed commands is
similar, in that it is a prolongation of messengerhood and the leader
and Imam to whom these tasks fall must like the Prophet be unassailably
immune to error in his words, actions, and deeds. To commit any error in
the exposition of God's commands would negate the whole purpose of the
Imamate, in just the same way that corrupt and unworthy rulers are a
threat to the authenticity of religion.
There can be absolutely no doubt that if the responsibility for
preserving and implementing the laws of religion is not entrusted to a
trustworthy and inerrant individual who heads the executive power and
applies them faithfully and integrally, the aims and purposes of
religion will suffer decay and distortion, for there is a possibility
that an unreliable and errant individual who heads the executive power
may implement the laws incorrectly or on the basis of incorrect
knowledge, or deliberately distort in conformity with his personal
desires and interests.
Furthermore, there are numerous verses of the Qur'an which call for
elucidation and interpretation by the Imam; it is he who must supply the
necessary clarifications.
One in whom all human perfections have been actualized is a complete
human exemplar of the religion. He embodies the state that is the
ultimate aim of man's evolution and is always situated on the straight
path which leads in that direction. He is inherently bound to act in
accordance with the shari'ah in every period of his life and is never
polluted by sin or impurity at any point in his life. If even a brief
portion of his life were to be spent in sin, resulting in a temporary
deviation from the straight path, he could no longer be regarded as an
exemplary individual, a perfect model of religion, and the divine aim of
providing men with the means of ascent toward Him could not be realized.
It is impossible therefore to renounce the principle that the one who
expounds and implements divine law must possess comprehensive inerrancy
and freedom from sin, even before his actual assumption of the Imamate.
Were it to be otherwise, society cold never submit to the guidance and
instructions of the Imam with full confidence.
Notes:
[214] al-Saduq, al-Amali, p. 376. |